Trademark Opposition Board Decisions

Decision Information

Decision Content

               RE: SECTION 45 PROCEEDINGS

                    Trade-mark: DIMENSION 4 & Design

                    Registration No. 311,652

Registration Date: February 28, 1986

At the request of Analyses Conseils Informations ACI, the

Registrar of Trade-marks issued a section 45 notice on January 13,

1992 to Dimension 4 Microcomputer Services (Canada) Inc., the
registered owner of the trade-mark DIMENSION 4
& Design,
registration No.
311,652. The trade-mark DIMENSION 4 & Design was

registered February 28, 1986 in association with "Computer software

designed for architectural/engineering offices in the nature of

project accounting and control systems", as well as services

identified as: "Conduct seminars for architects/engineers through-

out Canada in relation to the above mentioned wares".

 

In response to the Section 45 notice, the registrant submitted


 


the affidavit of Frank O/Connor, set out below.


Further, both


 


parties filed written submissions and neither party requested an

oral hearing.

1


 

AFFIDAVIT


 


 

CANADA

PROVINCE OF ONTARIO

To wit:


 

)
)
)
)
)
)


IN THE MATTER OF

SECTION 45 PROCEEDINGS
TRADE-MARK DIMENSION
4 DESIGN
REGISTRATION NO. TMA
311,652
FILE NO: 532,177


 


1.

I, FRANK O'CONNOR, of the Town of Pickering make oath and say:

 

1.              I am the President of Dimension 4 Microcomputer services
(Canada) Inc. which operates under the trademark Dimension 4.

 

2.            I have been using the trademark Dimension 4 since the date of
registration which occurred on February
28, 1986.

 

1.              The trademark Dimension 4 is used on all company business
cards, letter head, invoices, purchase orders and labels of
software discs and has been
used since the date of
registration and will continue to be used so long as I am. the
registered owner of Dimension 4 Microcomputer Services
(Canada) Inc. Attached hereto and marked as Exhibits are the
above-noted office stationery.

SWORN BEFORE ME at the Town

              of Pickering in the          )         

              Regional Municipality of      )

              Durham this 20 day of April,1992.) FRANK O'CONNOR

                 199                            )

 

The second paragraph of the O'Connor affidavit is a conclusion

 

of law with respect to the registrant's use of the trade-mark

 

DIMENSION 4 & Design and therefore does not assist the registrant

 

in this proceeding. In the third paragraph, the affiant refers to


 


 

a number of exhibits annexed to his affidavit.


The first exhibit


 


is a business card and the third exhibit is an envelope, both of


 


which bear the trade-mark DIMENSION 4 & Design.


 

These exhibits


 


merely confirm the manner of use by the registrant of its mark.

 

However, no evidence has been furnished by the registrant which

 

would relate either the business card or the envelope to use of the

 

registered trade-mark in association with any of the wares or

 

2


services covered in the registrant's registration. As a result,

this evidence does not assist the registrant in this proceeding.

The second exhibit appears to be a letter dated March 27,

1992. However, this document is dated subsequent to the date of

the section 45 notice and therefore is of little assistance insofar

as establishing use of the trade-mark DIMENSION 4 & Design as of

the date of the section 45 notice.

In view of the above, I have concluded that the registrant has

failed to show that its registered trade-mark DIMENSION 4 & Design

was in use in Canada by the registered owner in association with

either the wares or services covered in the present registration

within two years prior to the date of the section 45 notice, as

required by section 45 (1) of the Trade-marks Act as amended by
section
232(1) of the North American Free Trade Agreement
Implementation Act. Accordingly, and in the absence of an appeal
from this decision pursuant to the provisions of section
56 of the
Trade-marks Act, registration No.
311,652 will be expunged from the
register.


DATED AT HULL, QUEBEC THIS

 

G.W.Partington,
Chair
man,

Trade Marks Opposition Board.

"'


 

 

 

 

8th DAY OF

3


 


 

1994.


 

 

 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.